OK, so imagine you're a
diva who can actually sing the role of Turandot. And
you get hired for a production. And and the director says, "You'll never
be on stage alone. You will be surrounded by the female chorus, and they will
all be dressed exactly like you and move exactly like you. And they
all be will lip-synching your part with you. [Ed.: and some will
over-act*.] And, you will lip-synch all the choral parts
with them. So most of the audience won't even be able to tell you're the actual
diva."
![]() |
| Where's |
"Hmmmm," you
think in your diva brain, "I am not that egotistical, I
can handle that."
And then the
director says, "Oh by the way, the opera ends when Liu dies—there's no
big final happy ending duet. In fact, you die when Liu dies,
and that's it." If you're still on board, then you are an
exceptional diva!
So, they ended the performance where Puccini stopped writing, much as Arturo Toscanini did at its premiere almost 100 years ago. Toscanini stopped there because he wasn't pleased with either of Alfano's endings. And although the opera's also been completed by Luciano Berio (!!!), that ending didn't appeal to this director and maestro either. So they decided to follow Toscanini's lead. This shifts the focus away from Turandot's (less than convincing anyway) transformation from ice princess to love diva. And that's where Liu comes back in. She is in love with Calaf simply because he was nice to her. Not because she's bloodthirsty, vengeful, and unavailable. Calaf always seems more interested in "conquering" Turandot than actually loving her (or being in love with her). If he wanted love, Liu is right there for him. He's kind of a Pinkerton to me. But I digress.
So, they ended the performance where Puccini stopped writing, much as Arturo Toscanini did at its premiere almost 100 years ago. Toscanini stopped there because he wasn't pleased with either of Alfano's endings. And although the opera's also been completed by Luciano Berio (!!!), that ending didn't appeal to this director and maestro either. So they decided to follow Toscanini's lead. This shifts the focus away from Turandot's (less than convincing anyway) transformation from ice princess to love diva. And that's where Liu comes back in. She is in love with Calaf simply because he was nice to her. Not because she's bloodthirsty, vengeful, and unavailable. Calaf always seems more interested in "conquering" Turandot than actually loving her (or being in love with her). If he wanted love, Liu is right there for him. He's kind of a Pinkerton to me. But I digress.



